15 Best Tasty Pizza Places in Newark NJ (2024)
Ah, pizza – that heavenly combination of dough, cheese, and tantalizing toppings that has captured the hearts of people all around the world. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Newark, NJ has some hidden gems when it comes to pizza places.
So, get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey as we dive into the vibrant pizza scene in Newark. From classic New York-style slices to innovative twists on traditional favorites, this city in New Jersey has something for everyone.
Best Pizza Places in Newark, NJ
1. Blaze Pizza
Located at the bustling corner of Broad Street and Market Street, Blaze Pizza has quickly become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The trendy and modern interior sets the stage for a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience.
The open kitchen design allows you to witness the pizza-making process, from the dough being tossed to the toppings being added. It’s like having a front-row seat to a culinary masterpiece!
From classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms to more adventurous options like arugula and goat cheese, the possibilities are endless.
If decision-making isn’t your forte, Blaze Pizza also offers a selection of signature pizzas that are carefully crafted to perfection. Indulge in their mouthwatering “White Top” pizza, topped with creamy white sauce, mozzarella, applewood bacon, garlic, and oregano.
Or try their “BBQ Chicken” pizza, featuring tangy barbecue sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, and gorgonzola cheese.
Address: 691 Broad St, Newark, New Jersey
2. Mulberry Street Pizza
Located on Mulberry Street (hence the name), this beloved pizzeria has been dishing out delicious pies since 1933. With a rich history and a loyal customer base, Mulberry Street Pizza has undoubtedly left its mark on the local food scene and makes one of the best pizza places in Newark, NJ.
Mulberry Street Pizza is known for its thin-crust pies that are baked to perfection in a brick oven. The crust is crispy on the outside, yet delightfully soft on the inside—a true testament to the art of pizza-making.
Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or enjoy piling on the toppings, Mulberry Street Pizza is the pizza spot to visit in Newark. From tangy marinara sauce to gooey mozzarella cheese, every bite is a flavor explosion.
But pizza isn’t the only thing that Mulberry Street Pizza excels at. They also offer a variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes, such as pasta, calzones, and sandwiches.
What sets Mulberry Street Pizza apart from other pizzerias is not only its delicious food but also its warm and inviting atmosphere.
As soon as you step through the door, the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza will hit your nose. It’s the kind of place where you can enjoy a casual meal with friends or bring the whole family for a pizza feast.
Address: 258 Mulberry St, Newark, NJ
3. Queen Pizza – Places in Newark NJ
Founded by Italian immigrant Vito Morelli, Queen Pizza quickly became a neighborhood favorite, attracting pizza enthusiasts from far and wide. Over the years, the restaurant has passed down from generation to generation, preserving its original recipes and commitment to quality.
When it comes to pizza, Queen Pizza is the reigning monarch. Their secret lies in the simplicity and freshness of their ingredients.
The dough is made from scratch daily, using a traditional recipe that has been perfected over time. The sauce combines vine-ripened tomatoes with aromatic herbs and spices, resulting in a flavor explosion that is both familiar and extraordinary.
While pizza is undoubtedly the star attraction at Queen Pizza, their menu goes beyond just cheesy goodness. Explore an array of mouthwatering options, from savory calzones bursting with flavor to indulgent pasta dishes and cheesesteaks.
Don’t forget to pair your meal with a refreshing beverage or explore their selection of craft beers for the perfect accompaniment to your feast.
Address: 122 Halsey St, Newark, NJ
4. Pizza Village Cafe
Pizza Village Cafe has been serving up delicious New York-style pizzas since 1987, and it has become a beloved institution in Newark. With its rich history and commitment to quality, this family-owned and operated joint has gained a loyal customer base over the years.
Stepping into the cozy, retro-inspired interior, you’ll be transported back in time while savoring the aroma of freshly baked pizzas.
Each pizza is hand-tossed and made from scratch, ensuring a crispy yet chewy crust that will leave you wanting more. Their signature sauce, made from ripe tomatoes and secret spices, adds a burst of flavor that complements the fresh and locally sourced toppings.
From classic pepperoni to unique combinations like BBQ chicken or buffalo shrimp, there’s a pizza to satisfy every craving.
Located at the heart of Newark, Pizza Village Cafe is easily accessible by car or public transportation. It is just a short drive from Newark Penn Station, making it a convenient stop for commuters or visitors to the city.
Additionally, the pizzeria offers ample parking nearby, ensuring a hassle-free experience.
Address: 311 Ferry St, Newark, NJ
5. Brazilian Pizza
Newark, known for its lively cultural scene, is home to a diverse community of Brazilian immigrants who have brought their rich culinary heritage to the city. And what better way to celebrate this vibrant culture than through food?
Brazilian pizza joints have sprung up all over Newark, offering locals and adventurous food enthusiasts a unique twist on a beloved classic.
Brazilian pizza celebrates the fusion of flavors that define the country’s cuisine, resulting in a pie that’s bursting with vibrant ingredients and exciting combinations. These pizzas often feature thin crust, giving them a satisfying bite.
Their toppings range from traditional Italian ingredients like mozzarella and tomato sauce to Brazilian classics such as catupiry cheese, hearts of palm, and yucca flour.
This local neighborhood spot in Newark offers the perfect balance between Brazilian and Italian flavors with unique flavor toppings like chocolate and bananas. The pizza is packed with flavor for an inexpensive price.
Address: 97 Wilson Ave, Newark, NJ
6. Vinny’s Restaurant & Pizza
Vinny’s is not your average pizza joint. The friendly and attentive staff go above and beyond to ensure that every customer enjoys an unforgettable dining experience.
With a variety of toppings, crust styles, and sizes, their pizzas cater to all taste preferences. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita, a meat lover craving a loaded pie, or someone with dietary restrictions seeking gluten-free options, Vinny’s is the pizza spot to visit.
Each pizza is made from scratch using only the finest ingredients, resulting in a taste that will leave you craving more.
For years, this family-owned restaurant has been actively involved in supporting local schools, charities, and organizations. Vinny’s commitment to giving back to the community is an inspiring aspect of their business, and it’s heartwarming to know that every bite you take contributes to a greater cause.
Address: 22 Ferry St, Newark, NJ
7. Ellie’s Bistro – Pizza Places in Newark NJ
Located on a quiet street in Newark, Ellie’s Bistro offers a welcome respite from the hustle and bustle of the city. The rustic decor, cozy seating, and friendly staff create a comfortable ambiance that makes you feel right at home.
Their menu is a fusion of international flavors, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. From mouthwatering appetizers to delectable main courses, their diverse offerings are sure to tickle your taste buds.
Not only does Ellie’s Bistro serve delicious food, but they also present it in a way that is visually stunning. Each dish is a work of art, beautifully plated and garnished with attention to detail.
If you’re in Newark or planning a trip to the area, don’t miss out on the chance to experience Ellie’s Bistro. With its cozy ambiance, delightful menu, and culinary creativity, it is sure to leave a lasting impression.
Try their pizza bianco, arugula pizza, and house salad when you visit!
Address: 20 Green St, Newark, NJ
8. Farinella
As you step into Farinella, the first thing you’ll notice is the friendly and inviting atmosphere. The staff greets you with a warm smile, making you feel like a part of their family. Whether you’re looking for a cozy spot for a romantic date night or a place to catch up with friends, Farinella is the perfect pizza spot!
Farinella’s wood-fired pizzas are nothing short of perfection. The crispy yet chewy crust, topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients, is a match made in heaven.
If you’re a fan of the traditional Margherita or prefer Capricciosa, Farinella’s pizza menu has something to satisfy every craving.
Located in Newark, Farinella is easily accessible by public transportation, making it a great option for both locals and visitors. If you’re exploring the city or attending an event, this cozy Italian eatery is a must-visit.
Address: One Gateway Center, Newark, NJ
9. Dickie Dee’s
Dickie Dee’s is not your average food joint; it’s a slice of culinary history. This family-owned business has been a beloved staple in Newark since 1953, making it a true local institution.
Step inside the retro diner-style establishment, and you’ll immediately be transported back to a simpler time when jukeboxes were all the rage, and poodle skirts were the height of fashion.
For starters, sink your teeth into their famous hot dogs stuffed in pizza bread. These bad boys are made using a top-secret recipe, resulting in a tantalizing blend of flavors that will leave you craving more.
If you prefer classic cheese or crave something more adventurous, their pizzas are a slice of heaven. Make sure to try the pizza pie, meat lovers pizza, and a classic cheesesteak if you have room.
Address: 380 Bloomfield Ave, Newark, NJ
10. Mercato Tomato Pie
Explore this hidden gem that has been delighting locals and visitors alike with its mouthwatering tomato pies.
One of the things that sets Mercato Tomato Pie apart is the quality and freshness of their ingredients. The tomatoes they use are plump, juicy, and bursting with flavor. You can truly taste the difference in every bite.
From the traditional Margherita with fresh mozzarella to the Nduja pie topped with spicy salami and pecorino, there’s something for everyone. You can even customize your pie with a selection of toppings and create your own culinary masterpiece!
Walking into Mercato Tomato Pie feels like stepping into a warm Italian kitchen with a modern interior. The cozy ambiance, combined with the friendly staff, creates a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
Address: 212 Market St, Newark, NJ
11. Frank’s Pizzeria
At Frank’s Pizzeria, pizza-making is an art form. The secret to their delectable pies lies in their meticulous attention to detail and the quality of ingredients used.
Each pizza is made from scratch, starting with their homemade dough, which is lovingly kneaded and stretched to perfection. Then comes the tangy tomato sauce, made from a secret family recipe that has been passed down through generations.
One of the best things about Frank’s Pizzeria is the variety of toppings available. From pepperoni and sausage to fresh veggies and exotic ingredients, you’ll find a topping combination to suit your taste buds.
If you happen to find yourself in Newark, New Jersey, make sure to swing by Frank’s Pizzeria for a taste bud-tantalizing experience. With their commitment to quality, variety, and warm hospitality, it’s no wonder this pizzeria has stood the test of time.
Address: 161 Bloomfield Ave, Newark, NJ
12. Pizza Town Pizzeria
Pizza Town Pizzeria has been a local favorite since its opening in 1980. With its humble beginnings as a family-owned restaurant, it has evolved into a culinary institution renowned for its authentic Italian flavors.
The pizzeria’s dedication to quality ingredients and traditional techniques has made it a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts from near and far.
Walking through the doors of Pizza Town Pizzeria feels like stepping into a little slice of pizza heaven. The warm and inviting atmosphere, paired with the aroma of freshly baked dough, instantly whets your appetite.
While pizza is the star of the show at Pizza Town, the menu holds plenty of other delectable options for those seeking variety. From savory pasta dishes to crispy salads and mouthwatering sandwiches, there’s something to satisfy every craving.
Oh, and did I mention their heavenly garlic knots? They are like fluffy clouds of deliciousness that you won’t want to miss.
Address: 883 Mt Prospect Ave, Newark, NJ
13. Roberts Pizzeria – Pizza Places in Newark NJ
One of the secrets behind the mouthwatering taste of Roberts’ pizzas lies in the quality of the ingredients. They carefully source the freshest produce, premium meats, and top-notch cheeses to ensure every bite is bursting with flavors.
The combination of their homemade sauces and perfectly balanced toppings creates a symphony of taste that will leave you craving for more.
While Roberts Pizzeria is famous for its pizzas, they also offer a range of other delectable options. Treat yourself to their crispy, golden chicken wings or sink your teeth into their Italian style hot dogs.
Their menu also features a selection of pasta dishes, salads, and appetizers, making it a perfect place for a casual lunch or a satisfying dinner in Newark NJ.
So, if you find yourself wandering the streets of Newark, New Jersey, and your stomach starts rumbling, head over to Roberts Pizzeria. With its rich history and top-quality ingredients, it’s a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts.
Address: 63 New St, Newark, NJ
14. Pronto Cafe
Centrally located in Newark, Pronto Cafe is conveniently situated near popular attractions like the Newark Museum of Art, Prudential Center, and Military Park. With its prime location, it’s the perfect spot to fuel up before exploring the city or to unwind after a day of sightseeing.
Some of their highlighted menu items are the turkey sandwich, Italian cheeseburger, and or course their pizza.
Address: 48 Academy St, Newark, NJ
15. Nico Kitchen + Bar
As you step into Nico Kitchen + Bar, you’ll be greeted by an effortlessly chic interior that exudes a modern yet cozy vibe. The stylish decor, warm lighting, and comfortable seating create an ambiance that is perfect for both casual outings and special occasions.
Whether you’re looking for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner for two, Nico Kitchen + Bar is the perfect place.
This restaurant prides itself on its diverse menu that features both American classics and globally inspired dishes.
From mouthwatering appetizers like truffle mac and cheese bites and crispy calamari to hearty mains like their delectable short rib pappardelle and succulent salmon en papillote, every bite at Nico Kitchen + Bar is a treat for your taste buds.
The pizza is not the main dish at this restaurant, but they do make delicious Margherita pizza.
Address: One Center St, Newark, NJ
Pizza Places in Newark NJ Guide
From the classic New York-style slices to the innovative toppings that push the boundaries of what pizza can be, Newark has truly become a haven for pizza lovers. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Newark, NJ, there’s no doubt that these pizza places are worth a visit.
It is also worth checking out other restaurants with unique dishes like pizza burgers if you’re a real fan of pizza.
Head on over to the posts below to explore the food scene of New Jersey: